Central Ohio Real Estate
Debbie McNichols
614 207 7200614 207 7200


5 Parfy3c

Debbie is very friendly, personable, and an excellent communicator. She kept me informed at every step in the process. As a first time seller, I had a lot of questions and Debbie was always there with a smile and willing to help. I had a previous agent that couldn’t sell my house in 6-months. Debbie gave me great advise on what I needed to do to sell my house in today’s market.

I highly recommend anyone serious about buying to selling a home, to contact Debbie McNichols!

5 dvecchiarelli

Debbie was referred to me by another agent whom I trust completely. I have not been disappointed. Debbie is professional, knowledgeable, accessible, responsive and a great human being as well. I have no hesitation in recommending her highly.

5 ricciopeterj

My experience with debbie has been wonderful. She is honest, intelligent and professional at all times. She handled my home search and purchase as though it were her own. She is my realtor!

5 kristikrum

Just bought my first house via Debbie McNichols. Debbie coached me through the process, answering all of my questions and offering very helpful advice. I appreciate the genuine thoughtfulness of our wishes and her timely responses to all of our questions & concerns. I have already recommended her to house hunting friends. Don’t miss out!

5 Mlclay

Would highly recommend Debbie as an agent. She stayed on top of everything, you had a question you would get an answer right away.

5 reddevil2oo4

My wife and I met Debbie during an open house and we very much appreciated her style. In short, she was absolutely fantastic to work with and we would recommend her to any first time or other homebuyer. My wife and I were first time home buyers and extremely cautious with moving forward with the biggest purchase of our lives, but Debbie made it a much more comfortable process for us.

We ran into several issues during the actual home buying process (from the home inspection to the appraisal process) and Debbie was there every step of the way to guide us through each of the steps. She was very calming and for us, that helped in some of those moments of crises.

At the end of the day, Debbie took the time to explain to us what was going on, and really went out of her way to make sure that we were happy during the process and I would recommend her to anyone. Because of our work schedules, there were many evenings were we werent able to speak with her until well into the evening and Debbie always answered our calls and took our questions, even as late as 10PM at night. She was always available and extremely responsive to us. A call was never left unreturned.

We have been in our new home for just over two months and we absolutely love it.

Thanks Debbie!

5 buehrerandy

Debbie goes ABOVE and BEYOND! We could not have sold our house without her. She made our house sell and helped us find the perfect house. We were informed at all times. Debbie is a master of her trade and an extremely hard worker. She is also honest and very personable. We had a wonderful experience because of Debbie. I would recommend her to anyone!

5 cmills2278

Debbie was great to deal with! We were first time buyers and she made the entire process very easy and pleasureable. I would highley recommend her to anyone!

5 kkarling3

Debbie was a very knowledgable and patient realtor. She took the time to explain the process and helped us fine a great house to raise our children!

5 gshotts

It would be a mistake not to use her to find you the home or property you desire.My wife and I have had the best experience.Call her allow her to help you own a home we did and haven’t been sorry.I have the utmost respect for her abilities.

5 Johnna Jackson

I would highly recommend Debbie McNichols to anyone needing a real estate agent. She truly went above and beyond in helping us sell our home. I could not imagine doing it without her. Could not have been better!!

5 wally39

Debbie McNichols represented us in the sale of our home and the purchase of our condo. Throughout both of these transactions she showed a high level of knowledge of the market, expertise in contract, and concern for her clients. In the sale, an almost identical house was listed for sale. Ms. McNichols advised us as to what had to be done to our property and recommended a listing price. At the time of a downer market, we were in contract in 24 days. The other property is still on the market. While concluding the purchase, she saved us money that a charge was the sellers’ cost after explaining the matter to the seller’s agent.Ms. McNichols demonstrated similar skills in four transactions for our children.

5 user559868

We have had the opportunity to work with Debbie in the past. She has always been extremely helpful, not only in the sale or purchase of a home, but in all the extra things that go with what can become a stressful situation. Her professionalism combined with her personality have made her a joy to work with.

In fact we recently found ourselves in a situation in which we needed to find a new home in a rather quick fashion. We immediately called Debbie, knowing that she would be able to find us what we needed. She was not only extremely efficient in finding us our new home but stayed exactly within the parameters that we asked her to. In a matter of days we were able to find, make an offer, counter-offer, and get in contract on our new home.

Debbie’s knowledge, not only of the situation that we were in, but where the seller probably was, facilitated in a very quick and smooth process. While I am hopeful to be in this home for quite some time, I know that if we do have to relocate in the future my first call will be to Debbie McNichols.

5 user697149

I actually talked to Debbie about 2 years before I was actually in a good position to buy. Debbie kept in touch with my wife and I for the entire 2 years but was never pushy about finding a home. She created an easy website for us to track houses that meet our requirements so that we could keep an eye on the market in the area that we want. When we were ready to start looking Debbie showed us only houses that fit our likes and as we continued to look she narrowed the makret to a few that we liked in good areas. We found the house and made an offer based on a preapproval that we had with a local bank. The loan officer with that bank became very hard to deal with and Debbie was able to recommend a broker that was fantastic and helped us get everything closed before the deadline. I recommend Debbie for anyone that is looking in the Central Ohio area and will make sure that she is who I go to for any home buying needs that I have as long as she is around.

5 user2471933

I had fallen into a situation where the home I had found with my new job had fallen through. Debbie had found me a house to rent in under 24 hours and I was elated.

As difficult as moving to a new state and new job starts can be I don’t need to tell you how scared and stressed I was.

Debbie definitely came to the rescue and helped make a career ending and life altering situation go off without a hitch…

The house way exceeded my expectations and the owners I’m renting from are as pleasant and nice as she promises. I will definitely send anyone I know her way.

5 kgordon13

Debbie McNichols assisted my wife and I with the purchase of our first home. I have heard that the home buying process is a massive headache, but Debbie made it very easy and painless. She met with us over a holiday weekend on rather short notice and had already arranged some houses for us to tour that met all of our criteria. After finding the house of our dreams, we decided to extend an offer on the house. She had an entire packet put together with a ton of helpful information, and was able to answer all of our questions. She was very involved in every step of the buying process and has even stopped by and visited us at our new home a few times since we moved in. Debbie will definitely be helping us sell this house and buy the next one(s) whenever that may be and I highly recommend her to anyone in need of an agent.

5 user992431

The only thing I would improve about Debbie McNichols is the photo she uses on her postcards. She is even more attractive in person. She is cheerful, energetic, thorough, up-front, and very professional. Every call, text or e-mail to her is returned in a timely manner, and she solves problems as they come up. She answered every question I had about the sales process all along the way, and she is willing to work with others in finding solutions. In my case, she worked with another agent to help me.

I think Debbie was “right on” in establishing the asking price, and she worked well with my renters who were moving out within a month. She recommended a painter who did a perfect job throughout and who was more than reasonable. She was in my corner when anything needed to be addressed. While most of this was going on, I was in Florida. By the time I got to Ohio, one week after my renters moved out, the place was beautifully painted and three days later I received the offer I accepted.

I would highly recommend Debbie to anyone who is selling their property.

5 user8366072

Debbie was everything we expected from a realtor. After having a negative experience with a different realtor, we were relieved after we met with Debbie the first time. Debbie makes you feel comfortable and exhibits concern and understanding. She is honest, knowledgable and hard working. Debbie helped us list our home and made suggestions to help us sell. Once we received an offer, she was in constant contact with all parties. The contract fell through and she was able to help us locate a rentor. She helped us find our current home and made the buying process painless. We will definitely choose to have Debbie represent us in the future.

5 user49235911

Debbie both helped us sell our old home as well as find our new home. She was extremely helpful in answering our over-abundance of questions and had a great response time through both phone and email.

When selling our home, she gave us honest, helpful advice – ensuring that we both had realistic expectation, while being our advocate and champion during the selling process. We truly felt like she had our back, and wanted to make sure that we were being taken care of.

When looking for new homes, she provided us with multiple options within the area we were looking in – and was very patient with us as we tried to find the home that fit us best. She did a wonderful job of listening to what we liked and didn’t like about the homes we viewed and used that information to narrow our search until we found our current home – a perfect match!

While we expect to be in our current home for years to come, should the situation arise that we need to go through the selling/buying process again, at least we know that we don’t have to fret over finding another agent – because we won’t deal with anyone but Debbie in the future.

5 ward1102

Debbie is the best realtor I have ever worked with! I went through 5 realtors before I found her and I am so glad I did! She listened to my needs and gave me lots of options to look at. She stayed right with me threw everything and kept me informed. Her knowledge of the area was exactly what I needed. She really took the time to make sure my needs where met. I couldn’t be happier with her professionalism, personalization, knowledge and communication.

5 user7545877

We were so glad that we went with Debbie for our first home purchase. Debbie was just about everything you would want in a realtor. She gave very earnest advice at all the properties. She was good at being realistic, while at the same time, not making you feel that what your goals were out of reach. She was very knowledgeable about buying anything from move in ready homes in Dublin, 19th Century fixer uppers in Centerburg. She knew the buying process backwards and forwards. She helped expedite the process with the mortgage company when things got slow. Most importantly, she answered or responded quickly to all our phone calls (she would even pick up her phone at 10pm to answer frantic time sensitive questions). My wife and I would certainly recommend Debbie to anyone, and will almost assuredly go through Debbie for buying or selling in the future.

5 user6357523

Debbie was a fantastic realtor. I had talked to several realtors in the past about buying our first home and no one compared to Debbie. Being a first time home buyer can be very scary, frustrating, nerve racking and exciting and Debbie was there for the emotional rollercoaster right there with us. She replied to all questions and concerns in a timely manner and was very knowlegable about the homes, area and proccess. I will always do business with her and have recommended her to everyone I know going through a home buying or selling process. Highly recommend her as your realtor. 🙂

5 user2445405

Debbie did a great job helping us sell our house quickly and smoothly. We accepted an offer on the house in less than 25 days on the market, and had a VERY active period of showings before this. She was very helpful in answering questions, giving guidance, and providing reassurances. We had interviewed a few realtors before selecting Debbie, and she was the only one who came prepared with packets of information, a sample of the sales brochure she would use (already personalized with our house’s picture and information), etc.

Would recommend to all!

5 user03357013

My experience with Debbie was very memorable. It was my first experience with purchasing a home. Houses were selling like hotcakes and unfortunately for Debbie I didn’t really know where I wanted to live. I was interested in a huge area. Debbie was so kind to deal with me. I couldn’t make a single decision until I found the perfect house for me. We literally looked @ 10-15 houses all around the city. Some of the houses I even went back and forth on and revisited them 2 or 3 times before making a decision. Debbie was very understanding and helpful. I would definitely have her asy realtor again in the future. It was truly a great experience.

5 sheila l stewart33

Debbie has helped us many times with several of our houses and did a great job. I highly recommend her. Her pictures and advertising are top notch! Her recommendations for a sale have been very helpful as well. Sheila Stewart

5 mgnchaney

Debbie was all that you could ask for in a realtor. Extremely helpful, patient, knowledgeable, and remains in constant contact throughout the whole process and even after the closing.

5 Eric Nagy

Debbie was great to work with when she assisted my wife and I with purchasing our lot. She was always available to our questions and was a skilled negotiator. She was also knew the local market and was well respected by the sellers agent. She treated us with the up-most professionalism. I’d recommend her to anyone interested in buying or selling real estate.

5 kissell benjamin

Debbie is the best! She did a great job helping me refine my search, she helped me find lots of great properties, was very prompt and responsive in arranging walk-throughs, was extremely helpful in finding financing, and paid great attention to details in managing the purchase/closing process. Bottom-line I ended up with a great value, a great new home, and I’m really happy with the whole process.

5 jks79

My wife and I looked for a house off and on for almost two years. The entire time we were looking Debbie was with us. She is very knowledgeable, always responded quickly, and was patient with our on again off again searching. She’s kind, curtious, and we were lucky to have her to help us through the enormous undertaking of finding and buying a house. Debbie is truly top notch and we’d recommend her to anyone that’s looking to buy or sell a home.

5 batdad472

Debbie was a very helpful and knowledgeable realtor. She quickly returned all my calls and answered of my question. Debbie and I had a good relationship through out the months we worked together selling my house. I have worked with other realtor in the passed and Debbie was the the one most of the friendly of the realtors. For a good time and some fun along with business pick Debbie for your realtor.

5 slstanley74

Working with Debbie was a pleasant experience for us. She was always readily available to answer questions and show houses as fast as we could find them. We felt comfortable with the entire process. I highly recommend Debbie. And would defy use her again.

5 traceyzink

My husband and I were first-time home buyers and found Debbie after an internet search. She was incredibly knowledgeable, helpful, patient, and accommodating to us during the process. Despite our limited finances and throughout a fifteen month process, Debbie stayed positive and supportive to us in our search. Debbie provided reassurance on a personal level during a very stressful time and was invaluable to us purchasing our home. Debbie even provided referral resources for repairs after the closing as we remodeled the home. Her professionalism and passion for helping home buyers is incomparable and certainly exceeded any expectations we had. A recommendation for her services is given without any reservation.

5 michele borowski

Debbie turned what could have been an overwhelming process into an easy, pleasant and fruitful experience for us. She is very professional and also very personable. She really knows the real estate business!

5 pcoreno

Debbie is very good at understanding her clients needs and being able to address their questions or concerns. Debbie is also good at making the selling/buying process very easy and less stressful.

5 bmb416

Debbie was such a great realtor in the process of buying our first home! We were very impressed with how knowledgeable she was about the process and she did an even better job than our mortgage company at keeping us updated and in the loop! We would definitely recommend her to anyone, whether its a first home purchase or a tenth!

5 user7951216

Debbie was awesome! She took the time to understand my needs and wants. It took me a long time to choose a house and she stuck with me all the way. I love my house and recommend her to all my friends and family.

5 user6252849

We used Debbie McNichols to sell our house. However, our house was not easy to sell. We had listed it three previous times and had very few showings. I was skeptical that we would ever sell our home. We hired Debbie as our agent and we not only received more showings then all prior listings combined but most important, We sold it!

I believe the difference was Debbie’s experience compared to other agents. For an example, taking pictures of the inside of the property with the lights on is an important detail Debbie talked to us about. When you think about it, it makes perfect sense to show your house pictures as bright as possible. But if you take a look around at other listings you will notice leaving the lights off is still a common error.

That kind of knowledge only comes with experience. It’s those types of little things that Debbie does better than any others and it’s sometimes those little details that make all the difference.

You are in good hands with Debbie McNichols.

5 alyssasmith ams

Debbie was a fantastic partner in helping us relocate in 2013. She helped us buy our first home in 2011, and she was great at teaching us the ropes of purchasing a home. We needed to move for professional reasons, and within a matter of weeks, our home sold for asking price and we found our new dream home. I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend her to anyone. And, bonus: she makes the best cookies.

5 katevolley23

Debbie was verify friendly and worked hard to negotiate our terms with the seller. She was very responsive and always available for our calls. Plus she always brought us cookies! Highly recommend her.

5 got2bsherr

Debbie is one of the most efficient Realtors I have ever met. She is willing to work with you anyway you need her to. She has helped us purchase a home and selll two homes. Debbie is very knowledgeable and competent. We have another home to sell and will be using Debbie again soon. I would highly recommend her.

5 maggiehughes82

Debbie was AMAZING. We looked at 71 houses with her before we found our home. She stuck by us every house and was always keeping us encouraged. An honest, knowledgable realator who has literally become our friend. We will continue to use Debbie for our needs and refer as many people as we can to her.

5 user91032926

We were first time home buyers & Debbie was very helpful answering all of the questions we had. My wife and I work very different schedules, so we were only able to view homes on the weekends. Debbie was able to assist us viewing homes on both Saturday and Sunday. She also helped us narrow our search effectively, reducing the time spent looking at houses that would not have been good fits. On top of it all, she’s a very nice person to work with.

5 esgbcsteve

Our first home buying experience was very enjoyable with Debbie.She is highly professional,knowledgeable,timely and fun.She made it possible to purchase our dream home during a bidding battle. She brought her knowledge and experience cleverly writing the seller a letter helping us seal the deal. Our concerns were always attended to.We would recommend her to anybody. Young, older, single or family we’re sure Debbie will find you the perfect place to call home!

5 zuser20140619041559002

Working with Debbie to sell my mother’s home was so stress-free! She gave us helpful, specific advice regarding pricing and staging so we didn’t waste a lot of time once we were ready to put it on the market. She really knows the neighborhood and my family was confident and comfortable working with her on this emotional event.

5 johnson austin1120

My Wife and I were in search of our first home, and had no idea what to expect. We contacted many realtors regarding different properties, but never seemed to be taken seriously. The first time we contacted Debbie, she seemed more than willing to help, and began showing us properties immediately. We looked at many homes, and some multiple times, before we finally found the one for us, but Debbie never once got impatient with us. Once we finally found our home, Debbie was able to help out a lot in the pricing, and closing process with her negotiations skills. I would highly recommend Debbie to anyone looking for a home.

5 sp367805

Debbie was very patient with us as it took us awhile to find our home. She quickly responded to our text messages and phone calls throughout the process, and made it a priority to show us houses quickly as well. We would recommend her to others looking to buy a home.

5 hensleygirlsmom

Debbie was extremely helpful when it came to selling my grandmothers house! She went above and beyond my expectations for a realtor! I live in a town three hours away and Debbie took care of everything to expedite the sale of my grandmothers house making the process very easy for me! I had to trust her knowledge of the value of homes in the area and she did not disappoint me! I would highly recommend her to anyone selling or looking to buy a home! She was great!

5 zuser20140624042436824

Debbie was very professional, friendly and helpful from the very beginning. We appreciated her constant communication as we searched for a home and helpful insight on the housing market. She wanted us to get the school district we wanted! Sad to say, other realtors didn’t listen to our wishes. Debbie was also very patient with our questions and concerns. I would recommend Debbie to anyone searching and/or selling a home! Don’t look any further, Debbie is the realtor to get the job done!!!

5 parklane4

Debbie sold our home in 1 day! I can not say enough positive comments about Debbie. Trying to sell a home when you live 1500 miles away was going to be very difficult and challenging, so I thought. Not with Debbie. After interviewing several Real Estate Professionals, I felt Debbie was very driven, polished, knowledgeable and professional. After reviewing comps. in our area we selected an asking price that was not too high or too low. Debbie kept in contact daily throughout the whole process and would even stop in often to check on our home since it was vacant. She is very caring and relates well to all who are involved in the sale. I never felt pressured by Debbie to set a certain price or counter specific offers. She readily gave advice and encouragement but never pressured me. I am very very confident that if you select Debbie to work for you, she will do just that and get the offer you desire.

5 rdenzine

If you are looking for a realtor that will get to work and get results, look no further. Deb helped me purchase a property that was a very challenging transaction. However, she was able to help complete the transaction with consistent updates and communication. We were able to proceed with the sale and I could not be happier. I would highly recommend Debbie as a professional real estate agent.

5 user4950119

Debbie McNichols is incredibly professional. This was our first time selling a house and she took the time to explain to us what we should expect. She always answered our questions and took our calls. We felt comfortable with her knowledge and experience throughout the entire process. We would highly recommend Debbie.

5 levisp

Debbie is more than just a realtor. She will be there when you need more than realtor advice. She is willing to help if you need a helping hand and has names of professionals that work quickly to help sell your home and are reasonable with their pricing. If you panic about something she will listen to your concerns and give you advice to calm you down. Debbie has done a great job for me.

5 MarkNibert

Debbie is an incredible real estate agent. She is extremely knowledgeable and very helpful. From the first time we met her in July she was very confident and helped keep us focused and relaxed while selling our house. We were in Johnstown, Ohio and it is a smaller market but her confidence and knowledge helped us feel comfortable throughout the entire process. This was our first time selling and buying so we really needed it. She never hesitated to answer any of our questions throughout the process (we had a lot). She was quick to reply and never left us hanging. I never got the sense that we were bothering her either, I felt like she truly enjoyed working with us and her job in general. She is very passionate about her job and you can tell, I have no doubts in mind that anyone would enjoy working with her.

5 kehlcry

Debbie was professional and responsive. She kept me informed of the process every step of the way. She gave useful feedback on how to get the house ready to sell. She was very easy to work with. She was well informed of all the ins and outs of selling my house and was calm and reassuring when unexpected problems cropped up. She was able to resolve issues quickly and was willing to put in the extra work to get my home sold.

5 clraunikar

Debbie sold our house for us in about 4 days. She brought us two offers and helped negotiate the best price. She provided information when needed but never pressured us to make a decision. I have now bought a home from Debbie and sold one, and she has been fantastic both times. She is very knowledgable of the area and the market and works very hard to make sure you are happy. She is honest and hard working, pleasant, and never high pressure. And when we started looking to buy a home, she saved us from buying one that was overpriced by about $40,000 because she did her research but the seller’s agent did not.

5 shannon brunstetter

Debbie is a wonderful and knowledgeable Realtor. She is very helpful, and patient. She doesn’t push you into making a decision, but will take the time for you to find your perfect home. Through the process of helping us find our dream home, she became a great friend, and even though its been 6 months since closing, she still checks in on us. If you want a Realtor that will care about you as a person and family and not just a sale, I wholeheartedly recommend Debbie.

5 shermanm83

Debbie is excellent. She will go over and above what she needs to do for you. She showed me numerous homes, was helpful in doing paperwork, and was courteous and helpful in all aspects of buying a home. I can’t say enough good things about her.

5 heather marien

Debbie was wonderful! We were first time home buyers and didn’t have a clue on where to begin. After showing us several houses we came to the decision to build. With the decision to build Debbie was there every step of the way. With frequent phone calls to her panicking about the decision, she was so understanding and always helped calm me down. After a few problems close to closing (paperwork issues) Debbie was right on it, calling multiple people finding out what the issue was, making sure they sped things up. Even after closing Debbie came to the house to make sure a few problems were solved and still checks in on us! She was great and I would recommend anyone who is looking for a house to call Debbie:)

5 mfrancescon

Debbie was great to work with and was very knowledgeable about the local market. She was able to work with both parties and offer insight in a very professional way. She provided sale comps for the area and kept us up to date when a new sale happened. We were able to sign most of the documents electronically which saved us all time. She keep the deal moving forward by ensuring all timelines were met.

5 nncy nvs

What a great Realtor, she didn’t just list our house but was upfront about things we would need to update or fix in order to make it more appealing to a prospected buyer. She helped us get an affordable handy man and were able to accomplish everything from out of state. I would recommend Debbie to anyone looking for a Realtor and will be back to her should we ever return to Ohio.

5 bjpatrick101

Debbie was very professional and possessed in depth experience. She handled the entire process flawlessly from start to finish. Her ability to communicate was excellent.

5 user9462344

Debbie was great to work with! She helped us buy and sell. She was very prompt in notifying us of homes we might be interested in and was quick to list our house to sell. We had an offer in 3 weeks! She is very insightful and guided us along the way throughout the process. I highly recommend Debbie as a realtor.

5 Mcrara

Debbie was excellent! She was able to guide us and make recommendations when needed. We just moved to Ohio and needed someone with the local knowledge and connections. Debbie had both. We used her recommendations on financing and home inspections which made the home buying place easy and stress-free!

5 user90162271

My wife and I were referred to Debbie by one of my wife’s co-workers – and I’m glad! Debbie was extremely helpful to us as first-time buyers. She took the time to drive us around Columbus to show us the area months before we were even ready to buy. We were interested in some of the suburbs around the 270 loop; she helped us understand the pros and cons for each area so that we could ultimately decide with the best area to fit our needs. She walked us through the process step by step and made sure that we were comfortable and informed. The thing about Debbie that I appreciate the most is her honesty. She was open to sharing her opinions of the homes and areas we looked at. She never pressured us at all to make any kind of decision but she did give us valuable input on each home. On a few occasions she even shared with us that she thought the home was terrible! Using her knowledge, experience, honesty, and communication my wife and I found the perfect home for us at a great price – we could not be happier. She fought diligently for our interests during the negotiation phase so that we could walk away from the deal happy home buyers. I will be recommending Debbie to anyone that moves to or from the Columbus, OH area without a doubt – and I will continue to choose her to help us buy/sell in the future. Thank you, Debbie!

5 kchalfant26

Debbie was very patient with us while going through the whole process and helped us through contracts on a few different houses that didnt work out for one reason or another. She not only was someone who we worked with but also we felt became a great friend along the way. We really cant say enough nice things about her!

5 biems

Debbie is the kind of realtor that people HOPE that they’ve hired but more often than not, don’t end up actually getting. She is attentive, thorough, and very responsive (even after hours) The best compliment I can give Debbie is this: Even though she has sold a lot of houses this year, she made us feel like we were her only listing, and that we were her only clients. Debbie does a good job throughout the entire process from listing to negotiating a sale, to helping find a new home. She’s also very good at helping to counsel her clients on options. We loved working with Debbie.

5 cerdlr78

Debbie went above and beyond. The house we were interested in was appraised for less than we had offered so Debbie negotiated to have the list price decreased. She was always available to answer our questions and quick with the responses.

5 neally gray

Debbie was great and very helpful! We had not purchased a home in over 10 years, she helped us with the entire process and answered all questions along the way. Thanks Debbie!!

5 marc stakey

Debbie Has been fantastic. She has helped me previously find a home when I was in Dire straits because of a rental falling through. Now she’s helped me purchase 3 homes recently and every time she’s very professional, pleasant, and very reliable. She’s always made the process very painless and simple to work through. I will definitely recommend her and plan to use her services again in the future.

5 nichole lanning88

I have Dealt with a couple of different Realtors until I was referred to Debbie McNichols by a friend. I’ve known Debbie for about 6 years now. She is a wonderful person and has a great personality. She knows what her job is as a Realtor and she gets it done. If you find a house you want, she looks into the specifics first before she just takes you to the house for a showing. No point in taking a client to see a house if it won’t go VA or FHA or whatever loan choice you’re going with. She is definitely the best Realtor I’ve worked with.

5 JonathanOdum

Buying a home can be stressful….very stressful, but Debbie makes the process exciting and a joy. This is our second home purchase and Debbie was our realtor on both homes. She is beyond professional, and always motivated to get you exactly what you want without complaint even if it means looking at 30 homes (what we did lol). She also sold our first home and will coach you through exactly what needs to be done to sell in record breaking time. She works for you, which is something I don’t see too often. I will always use Debbie as my realtor. Great person and definitely excellent at what she does. Highly recommended!

5 sirani nichole

Debbie isn’t only an extremely experienced, honest and knowledgable realtor, but is also very quick to respond to any questions we’ve had in the entire process of moving and selling our house. My husband and I were lucky to have Debbie when we moved into our first house 6 years ago and this time as we sold our old and bought our new house. She made it as easy as possible and always was on our side if we had any altercations. She is also very patient, we were thinking about moving for about a year before we finally got into gear but she never pushed to hurry and was always there if we just had a random question.

5 lxlaroch

Debbie was a pleasure to work with. Selling a home can be an overwhelming experience but with Debbie’s support we had a much better understanding of the market and the process. She was dependable, flexible, patient and reliable. The process was very smooth and in the end our home sold in the timeframe and price point estimated. I will happily work with Debbie in the future.

5 jsharp71

Debbie is extremely hard working and personable! We were very happy to work with her! I would highly recommend Debbie to anyone looking to buy or sell a house and/or a lot. She is very efficient, friendly, and helpful!

5 selizabethfr

Debbie was very knowledgable and helpful throughout the selling process. In fact we were able to sell our home in under 24 hours. From the time we met Debbie until even today she is very attentive to any of our questions or needs and responds quickly either to text or voicemail. I would definitely recommend Debbie to anyone trying to sell their house and want it sold quickly.

5 john3665

Great personality. Trust worthy truly wantsto to help..my personal opinion a great asset for anyone buying or selling. We had Debbie look our house over for the best upgrades to help sell fast within 10 years and fond he knowledgeable and will to give real life advice

5 alexmoore43

Debbie was extremely knowledgeable in the home buying process. She was able to help us quickly purchase our top pick for a house in a very fast moving market. Debbie was also very resourceful and provided us with a list of loan officers, VA assistance, home inspectors, home improvement companies etc, which proved to be so helpful throughout the whole process. My wife and I are truly grateful for Debbie’s partnership and look forward to our new home, thanks Debbie!!!

5 elmoore8

5/5 starts, hands down!! We chose to contact Debbie to help us find our new home based on her positive reviews and years of experience… and we couldn’t have been more happy that Debbie was the one to help us find our home! Debbie was very professional through our whole process, yet she’s laid back and easy to talk to. As first time home buyers, we didn’t know much going into it all. Debbie was there for us every step of the way–she let us experience the process but was always available to answer questions and help us make the best decisions for our household. She wasn’t pushy at all and still made sure we understood what things would look like. Debbie also had tons of resources (banks, inspectors, contractors, etc.) that she’s worked with for years that made our home buying experience that much simpler…she never once led us astray. I would recommend Debbie to anyone in the housing market, buying or selling! Thank you, Debbie!

5 rcb1586

I met Debbie by requesting a showing on a house where she was the listing agent. She was very nice and helpful from the start. She showed me many houses over the course of almost a year and never pushed anything that I wasn’t interested in. When I finally found something I was interested in she was very helpful throughout the offer, inspection, and complete buying process. This was particularly helpful as a first time home buyer. I would have no issues at all recommending Debbie to friends, family, or anyone else.

5 user97533275

My wife and selected Debbie after she was highly recommended by a friend of our son. Debbie was always patient and responsive. She listened closely to our very particular wants and she worked very hard for months to find us our special house. She’s honest, personable and friendly and goes out of her way to help in any way possible. For example, she rented a metal detector and worked with me outside in the rain to find the rebar pins at our property corners! A remarkable lady and we’d highly recommend her to anyone seeking a real estate pro.

5 zuser20140311082333261

A few years ago, I sought Debbie’s help in finding a home. Since we hadn’t sold our present property at the time, she created an MLS site for me (within the parameters/price range that my husband and I selected) so that we could see what was available. Our son’s co-worker had suggested Debbie indicating that she a non-pressure kind of realtor and would be easy to work with. That certainly was the case. When we finally sold our property, we contacted her by phone and began going to “showings”. That began in mid Feb. and we closed on our new home/property the end of April. Debbie was very attentive to our needs and desires……working hard to help us find the perfect place. Debbie is honest, willing, personable and caring and I would highly recommend her for your real estate needs.

5 clotina76

Debbie is very knowledgeable about real estate, she really takes the time to listen to what you want. Debbie was always available when I needed her. I loved working with her and would do so again.

5 jeffsomerville110

Debbie is a very knowledgeable realtor who is always there when you need her. She made our buying experience easy and fun! Not only did she help us find our dream home, she has helped with lenders and contractors as well. I would highly recommend Debbie to anyone who is looking for an honest and dependable realtor.

5 christinae03

My husband and I worked with Debbie to buy our first home four years ago, and now to sell our home and purchase a new, larger home due to a job transfer. In both instances, Debbie has been responsive, flexible, and helpful with the buying and selling process. We never felt pressured with Debbie, even though it took months to find the perfect place to live. We always felt that she had our best interests in mind, and would go the extra mile for us, which is essential in today’s market. We would recommend Debbie McNichols without hesitation for any real estate needs you may have!

5 j m h jm

In short – Debbie was amazing as first time buyers (2014) and then sellers (2016). We hate that we relocated outside of the state (for my spouse’s job) because Debbie wouldn’t be able to continue helping us. Our toddler that was born at the house we bought with her loved her when we had to sell. Some more details here – Debbie was recommended to us by a former supervisor. When we first met, we were typical first time buyers that were lost in the process, super worried about having a bad agent, and just all around freaking out because everything was going to go wrong. We prepared a long list of questions for Debbie and met with her prior to committing. We left confident we didn’t even need to interview any other agents. My spouse was very picky about what the lot looked like. After the initial list was prepared, it got knocked down to just 5 potential houses. Debbie took us to see all 5 in one night. We really liked the last house and put an offer on it, which was ultimately accepted. There were no surprises or anything once we bought the house. Part of the closing agreement was that the previous owners were going to pay for 6 months of pest control. Ultimately, we had to get back in touch and work with Debbie to make sure we weren’t getting charged – the company quickly stopped harassing us. My spouse found out about a job back in our home state a couple of months ago. We immediately called Debbie just after my they even interviewed for the job – I wasn’t about to move if we were going to be taking a big hit on a house we had only lived in for about 26 months. Without even the promise of a listing, Debbie came over to our house, presented us with recent comps to get an idea for what we could list for and what our breakeven point would be. Thankfully, the market turned to fire for sellers just as we found out we would be moving back ‘home’. The house was listed about 11:30 am on a Tuesday. We had about 7 requests to show the house that same day with two offers before end of day and another three that arrived in the morning. Debbie presented us with a very easy to follow chart that kept to the facts about each of the five offers. Ultimately we picked the one we thought made the most sense. She set it up so we could sign the paperwork in the morning of our moving day so we wouldn’t have to drive back, deal with overnighting documents, etc. In the end, the buyer’s mortgage company (Chase Mortgage) couldn’t get their ducks in a row so we ended up closing a week late. Despite being at their mercy, Debbie was still pushing as hard as she could to accelerate the process. In the end, we walked about with over $20,000 profit on a house we lived in for just over 2 years!!! Keep in mind, our house was just a typical listing – not a foreclosure or anything like that. We love Debbie! I’m certain she would still answer questions for us should we have them while working with a new agent looking to settle in. She really became a friend 🙂 And she makes AMAZING chocolate chip cookies!!!!

5 katevolley23

I highly recommend Debbie McNichols as a realtor. She was very professional, knowledgeable, kind, patient, and helpful. My husband and I loved how communicative she was. I can fully appreciate this now, as our new realtor (had to move states) communicates everything via e-mail, even if it’s bad news. It makes me respect that Debbie always called us in person to talk. I think this helped us cope with bad news much better. Debbie gave us realistic expectations and advice for both our house purchase and selling that same house. She was so wonderful that we kept up on a personal level after we purchased our house. Once again, I highly recommend her. Don’t waste your time with anyone else!

5 jdh2323

A professional by any measure. Did an exceptionally good job in presenting our home through excellent pictures and vivid but concise language. Her assessment of the market relative to our home was right on target. Her attention and response to any concerns we had was always timely. We would recommend this individual to anyone in need of a competent, trustworthy and professional to assist them with their real estate needs. jdh & sah

5 zuser20150603175702782

Anyone looking for a realtor in the Columbus and surrounding areas should consider Debbie McNichols! Debbie helped my husband and I to sell AND buy a house this summer. She was very knowledgeable, responsive, and friendly. She went above and beyond more than once…even offering her own home to our cats when a short-term move was a possibility for us! Thankfully, we were able to move from one home to another without having to take her up on her generous offer. Debbie’s expertise made this life event very smooth for us. Thanks so much for all your advice and assistance, Debbie!!!

5 lydia navatsyk

We loved working with Debbie while we searched for our house. She was always available to meet up and look at houses when we needed to, and she responded to my calls/texts/emails almost immediately all the time. Sometimes I couldn’t believe how promptly she responded to me. The house we bought had a number of offers on it, and it was Debbie who pushed and pushed and got the seller to let us know what we needed to do to win the bidding war. And we did! I don’t think we would’ve been able to get our house without her.

5 jus10cox

Debbie helped my fiance and I purchase our first home. She made this nerve wracking process seem smooth and painless. She is extremely knowledgeable of Columbus and the surrounding areas and she helped us decide exactly what we wanted in our first home. Debbie answered all the questions we had. She was quick to respond and was easy to get a hold of whether through txt, phone call, or email.

5 kathyj322

Debbie did a awesome job of helping us find the perfect home. I was living out of state and my fiancé way there helping me get ready to move and when we got here she was always available to show us the homes we were interested in. She made herself available past regular business hours and was ALWAYS willing to help. Her negotiating skills were extremely helpful in us getting the perfect place for us. I would highly recommend Debbie to anyone seriously looking for your next home.

5 tackle62

Debbie was very knowledgeable and easy to work with. Responded in a timely manner to all questions! If she did not have the answer to the questions she found them out very fast. Great first time experience!

5 zuser20160321230040523

Debbie was extremely attentive and helpful through the whole process, and has continued as such even after closing. We are so happy that we found her, and would recommend her services to anybody looking to buy or sell a home.

5 gary addison6

When I signed with Debbie, I let her know I was most interested in her willingness to communicate and her ability to remove impediments to the process. She did both. A few times communications weren’t as quick as I would like but she is a very busy lady. More importantly we had to deal with some tough issues in this deal and she got in there and found resolutions to problems. Strong recommendation from me, she was also fun to work with.

5 zuser20161022154523219

We called Debbie looking for assistance as this was our first home purchase. Debbie was incredibly helpful on the phone and answered all of our questions without hesitation. After this we requested Debbie represent us as home buyers and she agreed. She was incredibly helpful, attentive, responsive and truly seemed to have our best interests in mind. We were able secure the exact house we wanted and Debbie helped us make great decisions with her experience.

5 s jasper1

She is extremely professional and a pleasure to work with. She sold the house in under 5 days and was quick to get the closing and the finalization done. She was quick to respond to any questions and concerns and worked very well with the buyers’ realtor. She made sure I sold the house for top dollar and gave me wonderful suggestions on how to make it look great! I would, and will, recommend to her all my friends and family!

5 gbucko53

Debbie was recommended to us by a friend of ours. We live out of state, so we weren’t sure how the selling process was going to work. Debbie was wonderful and made everything so easy. We communicated by e-mail, texts and phone calls. She addressed any questions we had right away, so we were never left hanging. Our house was under contract in less than a week after being put on the market. When we first met with her she was very honest and explained everything in detail. We would highly recommend her to anyone who is looking for a great realtor!

5 user23476074

Debby is awesome! She got to know us and what we wanted! She kept us in the loop at all times and made sure we understood what was going on at all times.

5 barbaraholbein27

Debbie helped us find the perfect house. With a very limited house market in the Columbus area, she was always on top of new listings and quickly brought them to our attention. She kept within the range of what we were looking for and acted in an efficient and professional manner. She was great in negotiating and extremely helpful in closing. A true pleasure to work with!

5 VincentStainbrook

Trustworthy advice, expert knowledge, responsive communication, and empathetic to your personal situation. Debbie is veteran realtor who was able to walk our family through the buying and selling of our home and condo. Debbie created a stress free process and went the extra mile to assure that our home sold at top dollar. She is a strong negotiator with a keen eye when it comes to the finer details of real estate contracts, and was able to explain what to expect throughout the entire process. Debbie also had a strong team of lenders, title attorneys, home inspectors, etc., who were able to ensure that there were no surprises. Most of all Debbie treated us like family, and we certainly wouldn’t hesitate to recommend her to ours. Definitely give Debbie a call!

5 zuser20160408170025952

We were first time home buyers while working with Debbie. Her knowledge and experience put us at ease and made the process move smoothly. She went above and beyond, meeting with us to view houses at random hours to accommodate my husband and my busy schedules. She kept us informed and on track throughout the entire process. After we found a house, she even brought us over snacks and cookies on move in day. It was very much appreciated and a thoughtful gesture that made move in day a bit less hectic. We are all settled in now and in love with our new home! Debbie is wonderful and we would recommend her to anyone buying a home!

5 dmillerinohio

We cant say enough good things about Debbie and her professionalism. Having dealt with other realtors that are very much into themselves and their personal branding, we found Debbie to be more personal and pragmatic with a very direct approach that truly addressed our concerns and requirements. We had some astounding circumstances with the house we chose to make an offer on, and Debbie was on our side every step of the way, surmounting any difficulties or obstacles with vigorous aplomb. She was always pleasant to talk to and had an answer ready for every question and situation all along the way, plus she prepared us ahead of time by educating us on the entire home buying process and timeline – she really took the time to give us all information and make sure we were up to date on everything as the sale progressed. We do not want to buy another house again for a very long time but if the circumstances arose, we would be making a call to Debbie first and without hesitation. Thank you very much for everything Debbie!

5 dmike5

Professional, high energy, communicative, high work ethic, knowledgeable, all which added up to selling our house after 1 hour to the first appointment scheduled. Advice was solid with results. Closing was when and were we needed it exactly and relations with the other realtor were very good. Not much else to say.

5 ccline0389

Debbie was great, very knowledgeable and honest. She answered all of our questions and made the homebuying process easy. We will definitely use her in the future and will recommend her for anyone looking to buy or sell a house.

5 tiara thurston

Debbie assisted us in buying a house in New Albany during our transition from Chicago. She was highly responsive and thought about all the details. She provided us with a list of wonderful Vendors which assisted us in quickly making the home ours. She even assisted in arranging cleaners so that we moved into a move in ready home. I appreciate Debbie so much! Thank you Debbie, you are the best!

5 Codydog1013

She immediately appreciated the unique value in the house (being one of a very few single story houses in the entire neighborhood.) She told us she thought it would sell in 10 days and close in 45. In fact, we accepted an offer at over the asking price within the first 24 hours and closed in 21 days. We live out of town and she was very helpful at stopping by the house to be sure everything was OK and keeping us informed throughout the process.

5 MandyRobinson8

Debbie was a pleasure to work with. She was flexible, knowledgeable, and I had complete faith in the guidance and advice that she gave me as a first time home buyer.

5 smwaspe

She was patient , Forever to find a house we really like but she looked and looked and looked forever to find a house we really liked but she looked and looked and looked for just the best house for us.. she was great

5 robisonlauren444

My significant other and I bought our first house with Debbie’s help. She patiently took the time to explain any questions while being both professional and genuine during a quick turn over market. She helped us check off everything on our wish list for an all around great experience!

View all reviews

Premier Lenders


Delaware County

Licking County